GUILTY MIND IN SEXUAL CRIMES

Authors

Mohamad Ismail Mohamad Yunus
Shamshina Mohamad Hanifa

Synopsis

“Actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea” which means an act does not constitute crime unless done with a guilty mind. A reasonable man is viewed as a moral agent and not simply as an instrument of causing harm. He is regarded as responsible for his actions. Being a responsible agent means that man is capable of reason (right-thinking person); he is capable of understanding the social and legal norms to which he is subjected; he possesses free will. He can thus control his actions and can choose whether to comply with the law or not. Several statutory provisions do not expressly contain any specific provision for mental element (means rea) in proving crimes committed. Nowhere in the Penal Code or elsewhere is there any general provision endorsing the doctrine of mens rea. Does this mean that liability in all such cases must be considered “strict” in the sense that no mental element or other criterion of blameworthiness need be established? For example, the offence of rape carrying a mximum to twenty years imprisonment undersection 376 (1) makes no reference to any mental element. What is position of an accused who honestly believes that the woman is consenting to sexual intercourse when in fact she is not? And what of the accused who honestly thinkf the girl in over 16 years of age when in fact she is not? Must such an accused person be convicted on the basisthat the doctrine of mens dea is inapplicable under the Penal Code? This book discusses the issue and other related matters on mens rea comparatively and it is necessary reference for the various parties involved in the administration of criminal justice including students studying the subject of criminal law and evidence.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Adams (1996).Criminal law and Practice in NZ, Student edn. Wellington (NZ): Brooke’s.

Adams (1998). Criminal Laws, 2nd student edn.Wellington (NZ): Brooker’s. Adams, F B (1971).Criminal Law and Practice in NZ. 2nd edn.Wellington: Sweet and Maxwell (NZ) Ltd.

Ahmad Zulkarnain Musa, Mahmud Hamdi Mahmud Saedon, Shahrul Mizan Ismail and Zukhairi Ahmad (2002). Rape: A Comparative Study, Law Majalla.

Al-Namir, Izat. Muhammad (1984). Jaraim al-‘Ifrd fi Qunanai-Uqubat I-Misri, Dar al-Arabia lil Mausu. Cairo.

Balasubramaniyam (1962). V, Essays on the Indian Penal Code. New Delhi, India: Tripathi.

Bargen, J, and Fishwick, E (1995). Sexual Assault: Law Reform: A National Perspective: A Report by Jenny Bargen and Elaine Fishwick for Office of the Status of Women. Queensland.

Brett, Walker & Williams (1977).Criminal Law, Text & Cases, 3th edn. Butterworth: Australia.

Brown D, Farrier, D, Neal D, and Weisbrot D. (1996). Criminal Laws: Materials and Commentary on Criminal Law and Process in New South Wales, 2nd edn. Sydney.

C.R. Williams (1983).Criminal Law Text and Cases.Butterworth.

Campbell (1979). Essays on Criminal Law in New Zealand 1. Butterworth.

Card, Cross and Jones (1995). Criminal Law, 13th. edn. London: Butterworth.

Charles F. Hemphill (1981). Women Law: A Guide to Legal Matters Vital to Women.

Clarkson (1987).Understanding Criminal Law. London. Consumers’ Association of Penang (1988). Rape in Malaysia.Penang.

Criminal Law Revision Committee (1984). Fifteenth Report: Sexual Offences. London: Her Majesty’s Stationary Office.

Criminal Law Revision Committee (1980).Working Paper on Sexual Offences. London: HMSO.

Cross & Jones (1972). An Introduction to Criminal Law. Butterworth. London.

D.S Sonnenberg (1969). Bourke’s Criminal Law, 2nd edn. Butterworth.

David Selfe and Vincent Burke (1998). Perspective on Sex, Crime and Society. Canvendish, London.

Department of Justice NZ(1968).Crimes in NZ. Wellington: Government Printer.

Federation Press (1990).

Fisse, B (1990). Howard’s Criminal Law. 5th edn. Sydney: The Law Book Company Ltd.

Fuerst, M.K (1994). Canada Practice Guide Criminal: Defending Sexual Offence Cases. Canada: Carswell.

Garrow and Turkington (1996). Criminal Law in New Zealand. Issue no. 26.

Garrow, Turkingston (1996). Criminal Law in NZ. 7th edn. Butterworth: Wellington.

Gilles (1993). Criminal Law. 3rd edn. Sydney: The Law Book Co. Ltd. Gour, Hari Singh (1980). Law Relating to Wrongful Restraint, Wrongful Confinement. Allahabad, India: Delhi Law House.

Gour’s (1955). The Penal Law of India. 6th edn.Vol. 2. India Delhi Law House.

Hail (1960). General Principles of Criminal Law. London.

Hale (1736). The History of the Pleas of the Crown, vol. 1.

Herliny and Kenny (1990). An Introduction to Criminal Law in Queensland and Western Australia. Sydney.

Hill, B, and Fletcher-Rogers, K (1997). Criminal Practice: Sexually Related Offences. London: Sweet and Maxwell Ltd.

Home Office (1995). Report of the Advisory Group on the Law of Rape. London: HMSO.

Howard C (1950). Australian Criminal Law. Australia.

K.L. Koh (1989). Criminal Law in Singapore & Malaysia. Malayan Law Journal. K. Lumpur.

Kate Warner (1998). The Laws of Australia. LBC, Australia.

Kelly, Liz (1988). Surviving Sexual Violence. Polity Press: Cambridge.

Kenny (1966). Outlines of Criminal Law. 19th edn. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.

Law Reform Commission of Victoria in Rape: Reform of Law and Procedure, Report Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Discussion Paper No. 12:

Sexual Offences Against Children (March 1988). Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Discussion Paper No. 2, Rape and Allied

Offences: Substantive Aspects (August 1986).

Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Discussion Paper No. 9, Rape and Allied Offences: Victims With Impaired Mental Functioning (January 1988).

Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Plain English and the Law: Guidelines for Drafting in Plain English app. 1.

Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Report No, 18: Sexual Offences against Children (Nov 1988).

Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Report No. 15: Sexual Offences Against People with Impaired Mental Functioning (June 1988).

Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Report No. 42, Rape: Reform of Law and Procedure: Interim report (June 1991).

Law Reform Commission of Victoria, Report No. 43, Rape: Reform of Law and Procedure (Sept 1991).

Law Reform Commission Of Victoria, Report No. 7, Rape and Allied Offences: Substantive Aspects (June 1987).

Laws of Malaysia, Penal code (F.M.S. cap. 45): (Incorporating All Amendments as at 25th June 1995) (Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia: International Law Book Services, 1995).

Louis M. Esteem (1942). Marriage Law in Bible and the Talmud. Harvard Semitic Studies, vol. 1. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Manohar, VR and Chitaley, WW (1980). The Indian Penal Code - XLV of 1860. vol. 2 & 3.3rd edn.

Maxwell (1910). London.

Mewett & Manning (1955). Criminal Law. 3rd edn. 1994.Toronto: Butterworth Canada Ltd.

Mewett & Manning (1955). Criminal Law. 2nd edn. 1994. Toronto: Butterworth Canada Ltd.

Misra, S N (1997). Indian Penal Code. Allahabad: Central Law Publications, 7th edn.

Mohamad Yunus, Mohamad Ismail (2014). A Commentary on Criminal law& Evidence. Kuala Lumpur. Marsden Law Book.

Mohamad Yunus, Mohamad Ismail. (2015). The Central Issue at the Rape Trial. Kuala Lumpur. IIUM Press.

Mohamad Ismail Bin Hj Mohamad Yunus. Doctrine of Mens Rea in Rape: A Comparative Appraisal, [2002] 1 MLJA 35.

Nik Rahim, Wajis (1995). The Crime of Hiraba in Islamic Law. New Caledonian University. Ph.D Thesis.

Murusason & McNamara (1997). Outline of Criminal Law. Butterworth.

Neal and Weisbrot (1996). Criminal Law: Materials and Commentary on Criminal Laws and Process in New South Wales, vol. 2 , 2nd edn. Sydney.

New Zealand Crimes Act 1961 - Revised 1996 (Wellington : Butterworths, 3rd

edn., 1996).

O’Malley, T (1996). Sexual Offences: Law, Policy and Punishment. Dublin: Round Hall Sweet and Maxwell.

Oxford (1989). The Concise Dictionary of Law. New York: Oxford University Press.

R.P Roulston (1995). Introduction to Criminal Law in New South Wales. Australia.

Rajasegaran, K (1995), Criminal Law. Leeds Publications: Singapore.

Ratanlal and Dirajlal (1988). Law of Crimes, vol. 1 & 2. Bharat Law House, New Delhi.

Richard, JB (1996). Criminal Law. University Casebrook Series. USA.

Robertson, JB (1996). Adams on Criminal Law. Brooker’s Ltd. Wellington.

Rook & Ward (1997). Sexual Offence. 2nd edn. Waterloo. England.

Rook & Ward (1990). Sexual Offences. Waterloo. England.

Sallmann/Chappell (1982). Adelaide Law Review Research Paper No. 3 Rape Law Reform in South Australia: A Study of the Background to the Reforms of 1975 and 1976 and of their Subsequent Impact (Adelaide: University of Adelaide.

Sallmann/Chappell, Rape Law Reform in South Australia: A Study of the Background to the Reforms of 1975 and 1976 and of their Subsequent Impact.

Scutt J (1990). Women and The Law. LBC, Sydney. Shaik, N.M., Woman In Muslim Society. International Islamic Publishers

(PVT) Ltd.:Karachi, Pakistan.

Simester A.P. (1998). Brookbanks, The Principle of Criminal Law. Wellington, NZ.

Sinhad, B S (1974). Principles of Criminal Law. Eastern Book Co. India.

Smart, Carol (1987). Proceeding of the 5th Australian Law and Siciety Conference.

Smith & Hogan (1988). Criminal Law. 6th edn. London: Butterworths& Co. Ltd.

Smith & Hogan (1992). Criminal Law. 7th edn. Butterworths& Co. Ltd., London.

Smith & Hogan (1996). Criminal Law, 8th edn. Butterworths& Co. Ltd., London.

Smith and Hogan (1965). Criminal Law. Butterworth, London.

Smith and Hogan (1996). Criminal Law, Cases and Materials. Butterworth, London.

Stuart and Delisle (1995). Learning Canadian Criminal Law. Carswell, Ontario, Canada.

Stuart D (1995). Canadian Criminal Law. 3rd edn. Carswell, Toronto.

Stuart D (1987). Canadian Criminal Law. 2nd edn. Carswell, Toronto.

Stuart, D (1995). Canadian Criminal Law: A Treatise. 3rd edn. Carswell, Canada.

Temkin, J (1987). Modern Legal Studies: Rape and the Legal Process. Sweet and Maxwell: London.

The Law Commission Consultation Paper No. 134, Criminal Law: Consent and Offences against the Person ( HMSO, London, Dec. 1993).

The Law Commission Consultation Paper No. 139, Criminal Law: Consent in The Criminal Law (: HMSO, London, 1993).

The Law Commission No. 177, Criminal Law: A Criminal Code for England and Wales (Commentary on Draft Criminal Code Bill) vol. 2 (HMSO, London, April 1989).

The Law Commission No. 177, Criminal Law: A Criminal Code for England and Wales (Report and Draft Criminal Code Bill) vol. 1 (HMSO, London, April 1989).

The Law Commission Working Paper No. 116, Rape within Marriage (HMSO, London).

The Law Commission, Criminal Law: Report on the Mental Element in Crime (Her Majesty’s Stationary Office, London, 1978).

Turner JWC, Russel on Crime 12th edn, (Stevens, London, 1964).

W.L Marshall (1990). Handbook of Sexual Assault. Plenium Press: New York.

Waller and Williams (1989). Criminal Law: Texts and Cases. 6th edn. Sydney.

Webster’s (1960). New International Dictionary. London: Springfield Mass, G & L Merriam Co.

Williams G (1961). Criminal Law, The General Part. 2nd edn. Butterworth, London.

Williams, G (1983). Criminal Law. 2nd edn. Stevens, London.

Wolff, Hans Julius (1939). Written and Unwritten Marriage in Hellenistic and Post Classical Roman Law. Hoverford, PA: American Philological Association.

Young, W (1983). Rape Study: A Discussion of Law and Practice, vol. 1.Dept. of Justice and Criminology: Wellington, New Zealand, 1983.

Zaleha Kamaruddin, Mahmood Sanusi and Nik Rahim Nik Wajis (1999). Women, Rape and the Law: Comparative Perspectives. IIUM Law Journal,Vol. 7 (2).

Published

1 January 2017

How to Cite

Mohamad Ismail Mohamad Yunus, & Shamshina Mohamad Hanifa. (2017). GUILTY MIND IN SEXUAL CRIMES. Penerbit UTHM. https://publisher.uthm.edu.my/omp/index.php/penerbituthm/catalog/book/158